Running shoe insoles: what they change in your shoe, and when they help
Last updated 2026-10-23
Written by David Kleman, who runs ShoeGeometry (not a clinician), drafted with AI assistance (how guides are made). Not reviewed by a medical professional. Research sources checked 2026-10-23; other sources are linked where they are used.
An insole changes the shoe it goes into: how high your foot sits, the drop, the room over your toes and the shape under your arch. What it does for injuries is more modest than insole marketing suggests. In heel-pain trials, off-the-shelf orthoses did as well as custom-made ones; benefits over sham insoles were small and short-lived where there were any; and the evidence on whether insoles prevent injuries comes mostly from military recruits, and is mixed. In pooled trials, shock-absorbing insoles were not found to prevent injuries. Choose by comfort, in the shoe you will run in, and change over gradually.
Sockliner, insole, orthosis
- Sockliner:
- the insole the shoe comes with, usually a few millimetres of foam.
- Insole:
- any replacement, from a thin flat liner to a contoured “support” insole.
- Orthosis (orthotic):
- an insert shaped to support or offload part of the foot. Prefabricated ones are sold off the shelf, some of them heat-mouldable, such as Formthotics (Formthotics); custom ones are made from a scan or cast of your foot.
- Metatarsal pad (pelotte):
- a small dome placed behind the ball of the foot to take pressure off it.
What an insole changes in your shoe
- How high your foot sits
- Stock insoles averaged 4.4 mm across the 483 running shoes in RunRepeat's lab database (October 2026), from about 1.7 to 8.8 mm; the Nike Alphafly 3's is 1.9 mm (RunRepeat). A replacement raises or lowers your foot by the difference: a 2 mm insole such as Icebug's Slim (Icebug, via Outnorth) in place of a 4–5 mm stock insole lowers it by 2–3 mm, and a thicker or more contoured one raises it.
- Room
- A higher foot has less room over the toes and less depth in the heel counter, so a thick insole can make a shoe feel short or let the heel slip (mechanical reasoning). That matters most where room is the point, as with bunions and Morton's neuroma.
- Drop
- The drop you run on includes the insole. If a replacement is 3 mm thicker than the stock insole at the heel and the same at the forefoot, the shoe runs about 3 mm higher in drop; a flatter one lowers it. Heel lifts are the extreme case (see the research below). Few insole makers publish heel and forefoot thickness, so compare the insoles side by side. What drop does.
- Under the arch
- Contoured insoles add material under the arch, often in low, medium and high versions; Icebug's Slim comes in three (Icebug, via Outnorth). Higher supports move pressure from the heel and inner forefoot onto the arch (Cheng 2022; Jor 2024). No study we found shows a best height.
- Cushioning and stiffness
- Cushioned insoles lowered the impact peak a little in runners in the lab (O'Leary 2008), but in pooled trials, mostly in military recruits, shock-absorbing insoles were not found to prevent injuries (Bonanno 2017). Carbon-fibre inserts stiffen the forefoot; in big-toe arthritis they eased pain slightly more than sham inserts, by less than a clinically important amount (Munteanu 2021; Munteanu 2024) (see the stiff big toe guide).
- Weight and water
- An insole adds or saves a few grams against the stock one, and foam that soaks up water gets heavier on wet runs, which is worth checking for trail running and orienteering (rule of thumb).
What the research shows
Each point says whose evidence it is: runners, military recruits, walking, or a clinical group not studied while running. Funding by insole makers is stated where we found it.
- Off-the-shelf or customClinical evidence, not in runners
In plantar heel pain, off-the-shelf orthoses did as well as custom-made ones, in a trial of 135 adults and in two reviews of about 20 trials each. Against sham insoles the benefit was small and short-lived where there was one: in the trial, better function at 3 months and no difference at 12; in one review, less pain at 7–12 weeks only, of uncertain importance; in the other, no difference from sham. The off-the-shelf device in the trial was a firm Formthotics (named in a later paper by the same group). Participants had heel pain and were not selected as runners. (Landorf 2006; Whittaker 2018; Rasenberg 2018; McCormick 2013)
- Custom insoles against sham and usual careClinical evidence, not in runners
In a trial of 185 adults with heel pain, custom insoles made by podiatrists did no better than sham insoles at 12 weeks, and those given usual care by their GP did better than the custom-insole group. The podiatrists' association paid for the insoles. (Rasenberg 2021)
- Pain at the front of the kneeClinical evidence, not in runners
In 179 adults with patellofemoral pain, off-the-shelf orthoses were rated as more improved than flat inserts at 6 weeks (pain and function scores did not differ significantly) and did about as well as physiotherapy; adding them to physiotherapy added nothing, and at a year the groups did not differ. The orthoses were heat-mouldable, fitted with comfort as the main goal, and donated by their maker (Vasyli), which had also paid one author. (Collins 2008)
- Runners with knee painRunning evidence
A review of trials in runners found very low to low certainty evidence that medial-wedged orthoses, among other treatments, ease patellofemoral pain in the short term. (Alexander 2022)
- Runners with overuse injuriesRunning evidence
In 99 runners with long-standing overuse injuries, custom orthoses worn for 8 weeks lowered pain and disability compared with carrying on without treatment. There was no sham insole, so part of the effect may be expectation. (Hirschmüller 2011)
- Preventing injuriesMilitary recruits in training
In a meta-analysis of trials, mostly in military recruits, foot orthoses lowered the risk of injury overall (by about 28 %) and of stress fractures (by about 41 %) but not of soft-tissue injuries, and trial quality varied greatly. A later trial in 306 naval recruits found 18 % injured with contoured off-the-shelf orthoses against 26 % with flat insoles, not statistically significant, and somewhat more side effects with the orthoses (20 % against 12 %, also not significant), most often blisters and arch pain; the maker of Formthotics donated both the orthoses and the flat insoles. Another military meta-analysis found no protective effect when trials were pooled. (Bonanno 2017; Bonanno 2018; Paradise 2024)
- Shock-absorbing insolesMilitary recruits in training
In the same meta-analysis, shock-absorbing insoles were not found to prevent injuries; the seven trials were of low quality and the stress-fracture estimate was very uncertain. In the other military review, one trial found fewer overuse injuries with neoprene insoles, but pooled trials showed no effect. (Bonanno 2017; Paradise 2024)
- What orthoses change in how you runRunning evidence
Posted orthoses reduced peak rearfoot eversion by about 2° in uninjured people (a review of walking and running studies), and in runners the change differed from one runner to the next, sometimes in opposite directions. Across 35 running studies in healthy adults, arch supports moved pressure from the heel and inner forefoot to the midfoot; custom orthoses felt more comfortable but made running slightly less economical. (Mills 2010; Nigg 2003; Jor 2024)
- Choosing by comfortRunning evidence
Researchers have proposed that runners who choose the most comfortable insert pick one that suits how they move; that is a proposal, not a tested rule. In 21 recreational runners, how comfortable an orthosis felt was related to measurable changes in movement and muscle activity. In a low-quality trial in 206 military personnel, every insert was rated more comfortable than none, and stress fractures and pain, recorded by questionnaire, were 1.5–13.4 % less frequent with inserts. (Nigg 2015; Mündermann 2003; Mündermann 2001)
- Where a metatarsal pad sitsClinical evidence, not in runners
Placement decides how well a pad works. In people with diabetic neuropathy, pads 6–11 mm behind the metatarsal heads consistently lowered pressure under them, by about a third, while pads more than about 2 mm in front of the heads raised it. In older adults walking, pads level with or in front of the heads also lowered forefoot pressure but raised it where the pad sat; only pads 5 mm behind the heads did not. The pads in that study were supplied free by their distributor. (Hastings 2007; Landorf 2020)
- Metatarsal pads in runnersRunning evidence
In 23 recreational runners on a treadmill, an orthosis with a metatarsal pad did not lower forefoot peak pressure compared with the basic orthosis, which already had a low pad; one with forefoot cushioning did, by about 10 %, and had the highest median comfort score. The pads were not placed for each runner, and the maker provided the orthoses. (Hähni 2016)
- Arch heightRunning evidence
In 15 recreational runners, higher arch supports moved peak pressure from the inner forefoot and heel onto the arch. We found no study that identified a best arch height for runners or linked arch height to comfort. (Cheng 2022)
- Heel lifts and stiffening insertsClinical evidence, not in runners
In-shoe heel lifts improved mid-portion Achilles symptoms more than calf exercises at 12 weeks in one trial, just short of the authors' minimum important difference; a review rates heel-lift evidence low to very low certainty. Carbon-fibre stiffening inserts eased big-toe arthritis pain more than sham inserts, by about 7 points on a 100-point scale, which a Cochrane review judged too small to be clinically important. (Rabusin 2021; Bourke 2024; Munteanu 2021; Munteanu 2024)
- How long insoles lastWalking evidence
Full-length, dual-density off-the-shelf orthoses (Formthotics) worn daily for a year or more by older adults redistributed pressure almost as well as new ones (heel peak pressure about 6 % higher than with new ones). Insoles for people with diabetic neuropathy compressed mostly in the first six months but kept their pressure relief for a year, and how compressed they looked did not tell whether they still worked. (Cronkwright 2011; Paton 2014)
Not known
- Whether off-the-shelf insoles prevent injuries in recreational runners: the prevention trials are mostly in military recruits.
- Which arch height suits whom, and whether matching an insole to your arch type helps.
- How many kilometres a running insole keeps working.
- Whether a thinner or thicker replacement insole changes injury risk: we found no study comparing insole thickness in runners.
- Whether home modifications like the ones under "What I use" help anyone else: untested.
Choosing and fitting one
Common advice unless a source is given.
- Take the stock insole out if it is removable (in some racing shoes, such as Nike's, it is glued in); otherwise use a thin insole on top of it.
- Match the length to the stock insole and trim the toe end. If you are between sizes, Icebug suggests the larger one, cut down with scissors (Icebug, via Skolyx).
- Try it in the shoe you will run in, with your running socks: check the room over your toes, heel slip and any pressure under the arch.
- Let comfort decide between the ones that fit; researchers have proposed that the most comfortable insert tends to suit how you move (Nigg 2015).
- Build up over a few weeks: a new insole changes the shoe. Icebug advises short periods first (Icebug, via Skolyx). In a knee-pain trial, mild side effects such as rubbing and blisters were about twice as common with orthoses as with flat inserts, and naval recruits given contoured orthoses reported somewhat more side effects than those with flat insoles (Collins 2008; Bonanno 2018). See changing shoes safely.
- A metatarsal pad works best just behind the ball of the foot; under it, it can raise pressure where it sits (Hastings 2007; Landorf 2020). A podiatrist can place it.
- Some racing shoes have a very thin stock insole and a snug upper, so a thin replacement fits best. At World Athletics ranking competitions, an athlete with a medical need can apply for permission to use a removable orthotic, and an approved one does not count towards the sole-thickness limit (World Athletics).
See someone rather than trying insoles if…
These are common warning signs, not a diagnosis. If one applies, have a physiotherapist, podiatrist or doctor look at it before changing shoes.
- pain is sharp, keeps getting worse or changes how you run;
- you have numbness, burning or tingling in the foot;
- you have diabetes or reduced feeling in your feet: insoles should then be chosen and checked with a clinician (common advice);
- off-the-shelf insoles have not helped after a few weeks: a podiatrist or physiotherapist can look at other treatment, including custom orthoses.
What I use
David, who runs this site. One runner's experience, not evidence.
I run with Icebug's Slim insoles, in the Low and Medium arch versions, which have a metatarsal pad (pelotte) built in. They are very good off the shelf: enough dynamic support to help but not intrusive, and decently light, including when wet.
For orienteering races I use Formthotics that I have spent a lot of time modifying: I add a pelotte, like the one built into the Slim, and take down the arch support. That is probably more work than many people would care for.
No affiliation with Icebug or Formthotics. Formthotics happen to be the off-the-shelf device in three of the studies above (Landorf 2006; Bonanno 2018; Cronkwright 2011), and the research, not my experience, is what to go on.
Sources
- RunRepeat, Nike Alphafly 3 lab review (its insole thickness, and the average across 483 shoes)
- Icebug Insoles Slim Medium, product description (Outnorth)
- Icebug Insoles Slim Low, product description (Skolyx)
- Formthotics, product features (heat-mouldable foam)
- World Athletics, Athletic Shoe Regulations C2.1A, rule 6 (2026)
- O'Leary K, et al. (2008). Effect of cushioned insoles on impact forces during running. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. PMID 18202332
- Cheng J, et al. (2022). Effects of arch support doses on the center of pressure and pressure distribution of running using statistical parametric mapping. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. PMID 36479433
- Jor A, et al. (2024). Effects of foot orthoses on running kinetics and kinematics: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Gait Posture. PMID 38367456
- Munteanu SE, et al. (2021). Shoe-stiffening inserts for first metatarsophalangeal joint osteoarthritis: a randomised trial. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. PMID 33588086
- Munteanu SE, et al. (2024). Non-surgical interventions for treating osteoarthritis of the big toe joint. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. PMID 38884172
- Bonanno DR, et al. (2017). Effectiveness of foot orthoses and shock-absorbing insoles for the prevention of injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med. PMID 27919918
- Collins N, et al. (2008). Foot orthoses and physiotherapy in the treatment of patellofemoral pain syndrome: randomised clinical trial. BMJ. PMID 18952682
- Bonanno DR, et al. (2018). Effectiveness of foot orthoses for the prevention of lower limb overuse injuries in naval recruits: a randomised controlled trial. Br J Sports Med. PMID 29056595
- Hastings MK, et al. (2007). Effect of metatarsal pad placement on plantar pressure in people with diabetes mellitus and peripheral neuropathy. Foot Ankle Int. PMID 17257544
- Landorf KB, et al. (2020). Effects of metatarsal domes on plantar pressures in older people with a history of forefoot pain. J Foot Ankle Res. PMID 32375847
- Landorf KB, et al. (2006). Effectiveness of foot orthoses to treat plantar fasciitis: a randomized trial. Arch Intern Med. PMID 16801514
- Whittaker GA, et al. (2018). Foot orthoses for plantar heel pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med. PMID 28935689
- Rasenberg N, et al. (2018). Efficacy of foot orthoses for the treatment of plantar heel pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med. PMID 29555795
- McCormick CJ, et al. (2013). The effect of customised and sham foot orthoses on plantar pressures. J Foot Ankle Res. PMID 23680496
- Rasenberg N, et al. (2021). Custom insoles versus sham and GP-led usual care in patients with plantar heel pain: results of the STAP-study - a randomised controlled trial. Br J Sports Med. PMID 32878869
- Alexander JLN, et al. (2022). Strategies to prevent and manage running-related knee injuries: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Br J Sports Med. PMID 36150753
- Hirschmüller A, et al. (2011). Clinical effectiveness of customised sport shoe orthoses for overuse injuries in runners: a randomised controlled study. Br J Sports Med. PMID 19679575
- Paradise SL, et al. (2024). Prescribed footwear and orthoses are not prophylactic in preventing lower extremity injuries in military tactical athletes: a systematic review with meta-analysis. BMJ Mil Health. PMID 34785586
- Mills K, et al. (2010). Foot orthoses and gait: a systematic review and meta-analysis of literature pertaining to potential mechanisms. Br J Sports Med. PMID 19996330
- Nigg BM, et al. (2003). Effect of shoe inserts on kinematics, center of pressure, and leg joint moments during running. Med Sci Sports Exerc. PMID 12569222
- Nigg BM, et al. (2015). Running shoes and running injuries: mythbusting and a proposal for two new paradigms: 'preferred movement path' and 'comfort filter'. Br J Sports Med. PMID 26221015
- Mündermann A, et al. (2003). Orthotic comfort is related to kinematics, kinetics, and EMG in recreational runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc. PMID 14523309
- Mündermann A, et al. (2001). Relationship between footwear comfort of shoe inserts and anthropometric and sensory factors. Med Sci Sports Exerc. PMID 11689747
- Hähni M, et al. (2016). The effect of foot orthoses with forefoot cushioning or metatarsal pad on forefoot peak plantar pressure in running. J Foot Ankle Res. PMID 27891180
- Rabusin CL, et al. (2021). Efficacy of heel lifts versus calf muscle eccentric exercise for mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy (HEALTHY): a randomised trial. Br J Sports Med. PMID 32988930
- Bourke J, et al. (2024). Efficacy of heel lifts for lower limb musculoskeletal conditions: a systematic review. J Foot Ankle Res. PMID 38878299
- Cronkwright DG, et al. (2011). Evaluation of the pressure-redistributing properties of prefabricated foot orthoses in older people after at least 12 months of wear. Gait Posture. PMID 21855344
- Paton JS, et al. (2014). A longitudinal investigation into the functional and physical durability of insoles used for the preventive management of neuropathic diabetic feet. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. PMID 24504577
Questions
- Do I need insoles for running?
- Not by default. Trials found small, short-term benefits for some complaints, such as heel pain and pain at the front of the knee. The evidence on whether insoles prevent injuries comes mostly from military recruits and is mixed, and shock-absorbing insoles were not found to prevent injuries. If your shoes are comfortable and nothing hurts, we found no trial in recreational runners showing that adding an insole helps.
- Are custom orthotics better than off-the-shelf insoles?
- In heel-pain trials and reviews, no: off-the-shelf orthoses did as well as custom-made ones, and in one trial custom insoles did no better than sham insoles. Whether custom devices suit feet that off-the-shelf shapes do not fit has not been tested.
- Do insoles change my shoe's drop?
- They can. The drop you run on includes the insole: one that is thicker at the heel, compared with the stock insole, than at the forefoot adds the difference. Few insole makers publish heel and forefoot thickness, so compare the two insoles side by side.
- Can I put an insole in a racing shoe?
- Usually, if it fits. Some racing shoes have a very thin stock insole that is glued in (the Nike Alphafly 3's is 1.9 mm) and a snug upper, so a thin insole goes on top of it. At World Athletics ranking competitions, an athlete with a medical need can apply for permission to use a removable orthotic.
- How long do insoles last?
- We found no study that measured it in running kilometres. Off-the-shelf orthoses redistributed pressure nearly as well after a year or more of daily wear by older adults, and in insoles for diabetic feet, how compressed an insole looked did not tell whether it still worked. A common rule of thumb is to replace one when it no longer feels the same, or when it cracks or goes flat.
- Where should a metatarsal pad go?
- Just behind the ball of the foot, not under it. In studies, pads 5–11 mm behind the metatarsal heads lowered the pressure under them; pads in front of the heads raised it in one study, and pads under the heads raised pressure where the pad sat.